Right now my home town, Hastings on Hudson (in addition to a few other surrounding towns), is considering a deer cull to handle the deer overpopulation issue. I usually don’t write about such local issues. But the Greenburgh Township Deer Committee wrote a 191 page report detailing their thoughts on the issue and why a cull is, in their opinion, necessary.
For pretty much all communities that face deer overpopulation, three issues rise to the surface:
1. Lyme Disease
2. Deer/Car Collisions
3. Gardens Getting Eaten (I know, this one is really pathetic)
After doing my own independent research and learning about the issues and alternatives to culls, it seems that the Greenburgh Township Deer Committee is adamant about killing things, even though other better ideas are totally possible.
The best example of an alternative option is immunocontraception. Basically, temporarily sterilizing deer with darts. You know, instead of killing them with bullets. This has worked in other places in the past and HSUS is really close to coming out with PZP for deer (currently being used on wild horses).
As for lyme disease, tic populations can be reduced through a variety of other ways, including Maxforce. The Maxforce lures mice, treats them with tic killer (leaving the mouse unharmed) and sends them on their way. What a great alternative way to lessen the lyme disease problem!
As for people’s gardens, put up fencing around your vegetable patch. Plant alternative flowers, ones that deer don’t like, instead of the ones deer like very much. A little research on the part of the town and a little education could go a long way.
We should be able to live together. We drove off all of the deer’s natural predators. We keep building new houses, roads, shopping malls in their homes. Give the creatures a break, show some compassion and think creatively.
At 8pm on Tuesday night Hastings is having a meeting and will allow public comments on the issue. They will also be giving an update on the deer situation. I know it’s a super local thing. But the idiotic Greenburgh Committee’s deer report recommended a 70% - 80% cull. That is a terrible terrible solution to a wildlife issue.
Also, you can contact Hastings through their website and tell them how you feel about it….